5 Hard Truths About Buying Gold & Silver

A table displaying a case of assorted coins alongside a magnifying glass for examination.

The Allure and the Reality

Gold’s allure is timeless, but the modern investor’s reality is anything but simple. For centuries, precious metals have represented stability and a tangible store of value. The history of gold and silver prices reveals important trends and market cycles that inform current investment decisions, helping customers make more informed choices. But behind the gleam lies a landscape of tax traps, ironclad contracts, and psychological pitfalls that can turn a safe haven into a costly mistake.

While precious metals certainly have their place in a diversified portfolio, the journey from enthusiastic buyer to savvy owner is paved with hidden details that can make or break an investment. Trusted by thousands of satisfied customers, industry leaders like JM Bullion—recognized as one of the largest, fastest, and most trusted online precious metals dealers in the U.S.—and SD Bullion, which has executed more than $5 billion in sales since its launch in 2012 and was listed as the 76th largest e-tailer in the United States in 2024, set the standard for reliability and trust. Bullion.com, with its knowledgeable staff boasting decades of combined experience, offers free shipping on orders over $199, most orders go out the same day, and provides a secure and seamless buying experience with no hidden fees. Customers can contact Bullion.com via live chat, email, or phone for assistance. SD Bullion guarantees the absolute lowest prices on gold and silver bullion in the industry. JM Bullion has no hidden fees and does not engage in phone solicitation calls. The launch of these online platforms has enhanced the customer experience, making it easy to add products to your cart, lock in prices, and complete your purchase with confidence. This article will uncover five of the most critical and often overlooked truths to help you invest with your eyes wide open.

Understanding Gold and Silver Products: What You’re Really Buying

Gold and silver coins

When you decide to invest in gold and silver, knowing exactly what you’re buying is just as important as the price you pay. The world of precious metals offers a wide selection of products, each with its own unique value, appeal, and purpose—whether you’re an investor seeking to build wealth for the future or a collector searching for that rare, premium piece.

Our company is committed to making your precious metals journey as transparent and secure as possible. We offer a broad range of gold bars, silver bullion, and platinum products, as well as popular gold and silver coins, silver bars, and silver rounds. Whether you’re looking for investment-grade bullion or rare collectibles, you’ll find a product that fits your goals and budget. We strive to keep our prices competitive, with no hidden fees, so you can shop with confidence knowing you’re getting good prices and real value.

Security and authenticity are our top priorities. Every product we offer undergoes a thorough verification process to ensure you receive only genuine, high-quality precious metals. Our website uses a secure connection for every transaction, so you can proceed with your purchase knowing your information is protected. If you ever have questions or need guidance, our responsive customer service team is ready to help—whether you want to review a product, verify details, or simply get advice on your next order.

We believe that knowledge is power. That’s why our website is packed with resources, from market news and analysis to a free investor’s guide, helping you make informed decisions at every step. You’ll find up-to-date information on spot prices, product worth, and the latest trends in gold and silver, so you can act with confidence and clarity.

Our products are sourced from reputable mints and refineries, ensuring that every bar, coin, and round meets the highest standards. For collectors, we offer a selection of premium and rare items, while investors can choose from a variety of gold and silver bars and coins designed to maximize value and liquidity.

At the end of the day, our goal is simple: to provide a reliable, fast, and secure service that leaves every customer happy with their purchase. Whether you’re adding to your cart for the first time or expanding an established portfolio, we’re here to help you achieve your investment goals. Explore our wide selection today and discover why so many investors and collectors trust us for their gold and silver needs.

1. Your Profits Could Face a Surprise 28% Tax Bill

One of the most jarring realities for new U.S. investors is how the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) views their shiny new assets. Far from being treated like a stock or a bond, the IRS classifies physical precious metals as "collectibles," putting them in the same category as fine art or vintage wine.

This classification has significant tax implications. While long-term capital gains from assets like stocks (held for over a year) are typically taxed at an average of 15% for most taxpayers, the rate for collectibles is much higher. Any profit you make from selling your physical gold or silver after holding it for more than a year is taxed at a hefty 28% rate. On a $10,000 profit, that's a 2,800 tax bill—1,300 more than an investor might expect from a typical stock sale. This is a crucial distinction that directly impacts your real-world returns.

Failing to account for the 28% "collectibles" tax rate is one of the most common and costly rookie mistakes in precious metals investing, directly eroding net returns at liquidation.

2. That "Buy Now" Button Creates an Ironclad Contract

In the world of online shopping, we're used to a forgiving "cancel order" button. Buying bullion is fundamentally different. When you place an order with a precious metals dealer, you are entering into what is legally considered a "binding and legally enforceable agreement."

Once your order is confirmed, you generally cannot cancel it. If you change your mind, your only option is to perform an "offsetting transaction," which means selling the metal back to the dealer at their current buy price. This policy creates a significant asymmetry of risk: the dealer is completely shielded from market downturns post-sale, while the buyer bears the full financial consequences of any price drop, plus administrative fees. For example, the terms and conditions from one major dealer, Stout Gold & Silver, are explicit:

All order offset requests are subject to our market loss policy... plus a $95.00 (USD) administrative fee.

This industry-standard practice protects dealers from market volatility, but it can be a costly shock for an unprepared buyer who thought they could simply click "cancel."

3. The Most Effective Scams Prey on Your Assumptions, Not Your Eyes

A gold coin and several coins are arranged on a table beside a magnifying glass, highlighting their details.

The most effective scams don’t target your ignorance; they weaponize your partial knowledge. Con artists know that new investors look for authenticity and purity, so they craft deceptions that seem legitimate on the surface while being fundamentally flawed.

While counterfeit coins exist, new investors are far more likely to be ensnared by two other tactics. The first involves promoting numismatic or “rare” coins at massive markups that have little chance of holding their resale value. The second, more subtle scam relies on deceptive language in advertising. Scammers know that buyers are looking for keywords related to purity and will craft their language to mislead without technically lying. As a precious metals dealer explained in an interview, this is how it works:

“…you got to listen for language like ‘layered in 999 silver’ or something like that. And they and and some of those people don’t hear them say that. And so they buy this coin thinking they’re getting this screaming deal…”

To protect yourself, take action by verifying the legitimacy of any dealer and performing thorough due diligence before buying gold and silver. Do not respond to cold calls, unsolicited emails, or pop-up dealers—always ensure communication is verified and legitimate. Purchase only from well-established and reputable dealers to ensure authenticity and avoid scams or counterfeit products. Before making a purchase, verify the dealer’s physical address and how long they have been operating. Consult local consumer organizations or state regulators to check the dealer’s history of complaints. Always ask for all fees, costs, and commissions in writing before signing a sales agreement or turning over any money. Be aware that fraudulent dealers may charge excessive fees and commissions, draining a significant portion of your savings.

4. The Greatest Threat to Your Investment Might Be... You

Unlike stocks or ETFs, physical bullion comes with a unique challenge: the responsibility for securing your investment falls entirely on you, and the consequences of a mistake can be devastating. Simply finding a clever hiding spot is not a security strategy.

Consider this cautionary tale, recounted by the owner of Stout Gold & Silver, an Amarillo-based dealer, during a 2024 interview:

"He bought a bunch of silver from us and he put him in PVC pipes sealed both ends of the PVC pipes and went and buried them in his backyard. Years went by... he went to go dig it up. Couldn't find it. He dug several holes around his backyard because he couldn't remember where he put it... he ended up renting like a backhoe and dug up his entire backyard. Never found it. It's just a heartbreaking story."

This illustrates the fundamental trade-off of physical ownership. Unlike digital assets or ETFs which carry counterparty risk—the risk that a third party will fail to deliver—physical bullion carries the unique and unforgiving risk of absolute, irrecoverable loss due to human error. This risk makes secure, professional storage a critical consideration that every bullion owner must take seriously.

5. Your Exit Strategy Is More Important Than Your Entry Point

Many investors pour all their energy into one thing: finding the lowest possible "premium" over the spot price when buying. In doing so, they completely fail to consider how they will eventually sell their holdings.

A dealer's buyback policy is a critical litmus test of their legitimacy and confidence in their own products. The absence of a public buyback policy is a major red flag, as it could leave you scrambling to find a buyer and potentially force you to sell at a significant discount. Furthermore, the existence of a policy is only the first step. A savvy investor scrutinizes the terms. What is the dealer's spread between their buy and sell price? A fair and transparent spread is the true sign of a dealer who operates in good faith, providing genuine liquidity rather than just a theoretical exit.

Before you ever commit to a purchase, there is one question you must ask every dealer: "What is your buyback policy?" Their answer will tell you everything you need to know.

Investing with Wisdom

The difference between a successful precious metals investor and a cautionary tale lies not in the asset, but in the awareness of its true costs. Investing in physical metals is a serious commitment that demands more diligence than popular culture suggests. Acknowledge the complexities of taxes, contracts, storage, and liquidity, and you can build a strategy that is as durable as the metal itself.

Scottsdale Mint 1oz Silver Marquee Peacock Bar

As Low As

Add to Cart

Any Year - 1oz American Gold Eagle

As Low As

Add to Cart

1oz Credit Suisse Gold Bar

Call ((806) 374-8698)

Ready to take control of your precious metals investments? Explore our range of gold and silver products today and make informed decisions with confidence. Start building your secure portfolio now.