Holy Grail Graded Morgan Silver Dollar Mystery Box

As low as:
Payment Method Qty 1+
Cash $250
Cashier's Check $250
Check $250
Wire $250
Credit Card $259.38
Paypal $259.38
+
As low as $250 per oz above spot

Experience the thrill of true numismatic treasure hunting with the Holy Grail Morgan Silver Dollar Mystery Box from Rogue’s Island Mint. Limited to only 1,000 boxes, each sealed package contains one authenticated, graded, pre-1922 Morgan Silver Dollar guaranteed by PCGS, NGC, or CAC. Every box offers the chance to uncover an elite rarity—including the legendary Holy Grail of the Morgan Dollar series.

Product Highlights

Limited Edition Release: Only 1,000 total boxes produced.

Guaranteed Silver: Each box contains one certified Morgan Silver Dollar, all original U.S. Mint issues from 1878–1921.

Top Prize – 1 in 1,000:

  • 1895 Morgan Silver Dollar Proof PCGS PR-63 CAM CAC (The current PCGS Price Guide lists the value of the 1895 U.S. Morgan Silver Dollar Proof PCGS PR 63 CAM at $85,000!)

  Universally recognized as *the* key to the Morgan Dollar series, with unmatched scarcity and prestige.

2nd-Tier Chase – 1 in 10:

  • 100× Carson City Morgan Silver Dollars – CAC Graded

  Highly desirable CC-minted Morgans, each hand-selected and CAC-approved.

Guaranteed Grade:

  • Remaining 899 boxes contain a Mint State Morgan Silver Dollar (MS-graded) certified by PCGS or NGC.

Securely Packaged: Each box is factory-sealed to preserve the integrity and excitement of the reveal.

Perfect for Collectors & Investors: A unique opportunity to acquire slabbed, investment-grade Morgans with the chance at exceptional numismatic rarities.

The Holy Grail Prize
The 1895 Proof Morgan Dollar is one of the most coveted coins in U.S. numismatics due to its extreme rarity and iconic status. With only a tiny number surviving in collectible condition, it stands as a pinnacle piece for advanced Morgan Dollar enthusiasts. The inclusion of a **PCGS PR-63 CAM CAC** example makes this mystery box one of the most exciting numismatic offerings available today.

Why Choose the Holy Grail Morgan Mystery Box?
Combining historical significance, certified authenticity, and the exhilarating chance at ultra-rare coins, this box offers unmatched value for both collectors and investors. Whether you’re seeking a high-quality MS Morgan or hoping to unveil the legendary 1895 Proof, each box provides a rewarding experience backed by Rogue’s Island Mint’s reputation for premium curated releases.

Add a Box to Your Collection Today
Morgan Dollars are among the most beloved American coinage series—rich with history, artistry, and enduring demand. With only 1,000 boxes available and chase coins of extraordinary rarity, the Holy Grail Morgan Silver Dollar Mystery Box is expected to sell out quickly. Secure yours while supplies last.


★★★★★

‘’I would highly recommend making online purchases from Stout Gold & Silver. I was a little hesitant at first because it was going to be my first time purchasing from them so I gave them a call and they took extra time to walk me through the process. Turns out there was not much to it, I placed the order for check payment, mailed off my check and they sent me an update when my order was being shipped out. All the pieces of silver came exactly as described and were undamaged, they did a very good job packaging the pieces. All and all, I am very satisfied and look forward to placing my next order with them. I hope this is helpful comment for anyone interested in doing business with them.’’

Steven Holzworth
Verified Customer
★★★★★

‘’ Started buying silver coins a few years ago, great service, honest prices. I always deal with a guy named Brett, he is pretty funny, super helpful, and very nice. 10/10 would buy again from them. ’’

Adam Schaer
Verified Customer
★★★★★

‘’Best Gold and Silver dealer bar none! And the safe storage is both affordable and very secure. This business also has the advantage of being owned run by Tom Stout, who i would trust with just about anything. Admittedly I'm friends with Tom as well as a customer but he really is a man of his word, if he says it, that's the way it's going to happen.’’

Ronald Cox
Verified Customer
★★★★★

‘’Ordered a 1986 Proor Libertad and was very pleased with my purchase! Great price and super fast shipping with no hassle. It even came with the original box and I thought it was just the coin. I work at a coin shop and it’s great to do business with other great coin shops. I highly recommend this shop! Thanks for the amazing coin!’’

Chase Aldredge
Verified Customer
★★★★★

‘’Stout is very dependable and willing to make sure you get what you want! Thanks for the great service!’’

ChrisNée Cooper Herrera
Verified Customer
PCGS logo
NGC Logo
ANA Logo
BBB logo
ICTA logo

Family owned and operated in the Texas Panhandle since 1986.

Your Cart


Continue to Checkout